Hong Kong’s Jimmy Lai ignored objections to his letter campaign to Donald Trump, said being ‘brave’ only way to stop security law, court hears

Chan, a defendant turned prosecution witness, said the initiative would have been fine had Lai run the advertisements in his personal capacity instead of launching it under Apple Daily’s name.

She added her supervisor, former publisher Cheung Kim-hung, was “not very eager” to follow his boss’ instructions either.

But Lai stood his ground, saying in a text message that they could not “pretend to be careful and clever” at a time of crisis.

Jimmy Lai trial told Hong Kong tycoon used political figures to back Apple Daily

“The only way is to be brave! There’s no other way to deal with [the Chinese Communist Party] now,” the tycoon added.

Lai, 76, is being tried on two conspiracy counts of collusion with foreign forces under the national security law, as well as a third count of conspiracy to print and distribute seditious publications under colonial-era legislation.

Prosecutors are seeking to establish a case that Apple Daily excited public disaffection with the new law and used it as an excuse to instigate hostile actions from overseas countries against Beijing and local authorities.

They highlighted text conversations between Lai and senior editorial staff following an official announcement about Beijing’s plan to craft and pass the national security law.

“Damn it, it’s coming!” Lai said in one such dialogue.

‘Hong Kong’s Lai told Apple Daily to play up Beijing’s alleged Covid cover-up’

The court heard the tycoon later asked Chan to regularly feed him ideas to write on his personal social media account.

Chan on one occasion suggested that Lai write about the “Hong Kong traitors” who supported the national security law.

She said a statement of support by Henry Tang Ying-yen, a member of the Standing Committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC), “disgusted many Hong Kong people”.

Lai subsequently tweeted a picture of Tang and other CPPCC members behind a banner that said “support national security legislation, safeguard ‘one country, two systems’ [governing principle]” and questioned whether “the US government [should] put them on the sanction list”.

Hong Kong police raid Apple Daily newspaper offices at the Next Digital Limited building in Tseung Kwan O back in August 2020. Photo: Winson Wong

Separately, prosecutors asked Chan to explain Apple Daily’s decision to run a series of allegedly seditious publications at a time when “riots and protests” were still gripping the city.

Ivan Cheung Cheuk-kan, for the prosecution, pointed to an award-winning Apple Daily mini-site in May 2020 focusing on the alleged detention and persecution of Uygurs and other ethnic Muslim groups in Xinjiang.

An introductory statement of the webpage said the Chinese Communist Party, “descending like a devil”, had turned China’s far west region into a “city-sized jail”.

‘Lai asked top Apple Daily executive to encourage Hongkongers to protest 2019 bill’

Chan confirmed the digital content also appeared on the tabloid’s print edition, noting the report detailed the plight of ethnic minorities locked up in “correctional facilities”.
Cheung also questioned the newspaper’s decision to run a story in June 2020 on fugitive activist Finn Lau Cho-dick, who was known for advocating “mutual destruction” overseas, and the Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China, which had called for sanctions against Beijing and Hong Kong officials.

The witness denied playing up the story with an ulterior motive, noting the alliance was newly established at the time and that other news outlets also had produced reports about the activist.

Cheung turned his focus to another report the same month about a jail sentence handed to a social worker involved in the 2019 anti-government protests.
The prosecutor suggested Apple Daily had made its stance clear in a supplementary report focusing on the sentencing magistrate, Don So Man-lung, saying he had previously praised an assailant in a notorious railway station attack in 2019 when releasing him on bail.

Hong Kong’s Jimmy Lai told Apple Daily not to target Donald Trump, court hears

Chan explained the case had generated controversies in the social work sector, with some feeling the ruling was too harsh.

The court also heard Lai had asked Apple Daily to play up the United States’ responses to the 31st anniversary of the 1989 Tiananmen Square crackdown, including a meeting between then secretary of state Mike Pompeo and surviving protesters.

In a message originally addressed to Lai, Mark Simon, his right-hand man and a former US intelligence agent, said “our friend in Pompeo’s team” was concerned “the message is not reaching the Hong Kong community because of the dominance of pro-Beijing news organisations”.

The tabloid later ran a story titled “Pompeo stands with dissidents” as part of its report on the anniversary.

Chan, however, explained that Simon’s prompt message and the subsequent report were unrelated, as Lai was merely asking at the time whether the tabloid had run a story on Pompeo.

The trial continues on Thursday.