LOVE Island fans are convinced that Toby Aromolaran confessed to "cheating" on Chloe Burrows as he revealed he bedded Arabella Chi.
Toby, 24, and Arabella, 32, came face-to-face on Love Island All Stars after it was previously revealed that there was "history" between the pair.
Arabella revealed to the girls that she had a "fling" with Toby 18 months ago, which would be around July 2022.
But Toby ended his romance with his Love Island ex Chloe in October 2022.
ITV2 viewers were confused by the dates and said it didn't add up.
One wrote: "When did Toby and Chloe break up for him to have this fling with Arabella."
READ MORE ON LOVE ISLAND
A second posted: "Split up October 2022. Year and a half ago would make it July 2022 for the fling."
"The answer you’re looking for is cheating," a third commented.
A fourth added: "They broke up in October 2022. I did the math and he said they were texting 1.5 years ago.. aka! JUNE OF 2022!"
Arabella confirmed that they slept together during a one night stand but later admitted she was hazy on the date it happened.
Toby, however, denied that the pair had had sex, unaware that Arabella had revealed all to Georgia.
Chloe and Toby confirmed the end of their romance in October 2022, just over a year after they left their series of the ITV2 dating show together.
A source told The Sun at the time of their split: "Chloe and Toby have decided to go their separate ways.
"They have grown apart and there's no major hard feelings.
"Toby is currently staying with a friend while they work out what t
Toby previously opened up about his relationship breakdown with Chloe.
He previously said that he "couldn't trust" the star anymore after revealing a 'big incident' on a night out led to the end of their romance.
